Meet the Team
At Nauyokas Insurance Agency, the core of our company is simple: clear guidance, strong protection, and a commitment to the people we serve.
We believe insurance should be understood before it is ever needed. That’s why we take the time to explain your coverage, answer your questions, and make sure you know exactly what you have and why it matters.
We also know that budget matters. Our role is to help you find the right balance between cost and protection without sacrificing the coverage that protects what matters most. Instead of focusing only on price, we focus on building policies designed to hold up when life takes an unexpected turn.
Most importantly, we believe insurance is about people. When challenges happen, we stand with our clients, help them navigate the process, and work to make sure they are taken care of when it matters most.
That commitment to clarity, protection, and people is the foundation of everything we do.
Meet the team behind the coverage.
We are here to guide you, close the gaps most people miss, and build protection that actually works when life goes wrong.
John Nauyokas
john@nauyokasins.com
Agency Owner & Agent
With a lifetime dedicated to service, I bring a different perspective to protecting what matters most.
I spent 32 years as a Respiratory Therapist and 9 years as a Firefighter Medic. I have been on the scene when life changed in an instant. I have also seen what happens when coverage is missing or does not work the way people thought it would.
That experience drives how I build policies today.
I focus on clear guidance and strong protection that fits your budget. Every client works directly with me. We go through your coverage together so you understand exactly what you have and how it performs when it matters.
My commitment to you:
• Identify hidden coverage gaps
• Build protection first, not just chase the lowest price
• Walk through how a claim would actually work in real life
My job is simple. Help you make informed decisions so your home, your family, and everything you have worked for is protected when life does not go as planned.
Teresa Nauyokas
Business Support Manager
teresa@nauyokasins.com
Teresa serves full time as a Registered Nurse Case Manager at IU Arnett, working closely with patients and families through complex medical situations and major life transitions.
Her background includes years in pulmonary care, critical care support, and hospice, where attention to detail and doing things right directly impact outcomes .
Within the agency, Teresa supports the business behind the scenes during nights and weekends. She helps manage bill pay, coordinates supplies and equipment, and keeps operations moving so the team can stay focused on clients.
She also plays a key role in the personal side of the business, organizing client welcomes, team recognition, and important moments like birthdays. Those details matter. They help build relationships and create an experience people remember.
Her influence shows up in both how the agency runs and how people are cared for.
What Clients Say About Working with Our Team
John is a rare combination of someone who genuinely wants to do the right thing for the people he serves while also maintaining strong business discipline. His integrity, professionalism, and focus on doing what is best for his clients make him someone you can truly trust.
Ed L
John has always been deeply committed to helping others and doing what is right for the people he serves. His leadership and dedication to those in his care stood out throughout his career. That same commitment to integrity and service carries into the way he works with clients today.
Dianna K
I worked with John for two years and found him to be one of the most loyal, compassionate, and hardworking professionals I have ever had the privilege to work with. His commitment to helping others and supporting those around him truly stands out.
LeeOnna A
John is a great person to work with and always willing to help educate others and provide support when it is needed. His professionalism and commitment to service make him someone I highly recommend.
Darwin S
A Neighbor You Can Lean On
712 Adams St, Carmel IN 46032
Phone: 317-660-1710
Office Hours
Monday - Friday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday & Sunday: Closed
Deeply rooted in our community, we proudly serve families and businesses across Carmel, Westfield, Zionsville, and the greater Indiana area with local expertise you can trust. Connect with John, Teresa, and Madison for personalized insurance guidance.
Schedule a Coverage Review
Most people do not realize there are gaps in their coverage until something goes wrong.
A coverage review is where we take a close look at what you have today, how it is built, and where it could fail. We walk through real scenarios so you understand exactly how your policy would respond in a claim.
The goal is simple. Make sure your protection actually works when you need it.
Most people believe they are fully covered. The numbers say otherwise.
• 60% of homes are underinsured
• 1 in 3 cannot fully rebuild after a loss
• Most policies have not been reviewed in years
That is why a coverage review matters.