Meet John Nauyokas
John Nauyokas brings a real-world perspective to insurance. His background as a respiratory therapist, firefighter, and paramedic has shaped the way he thinks about protection, preparation, and the people behind every policy.
After years of seeing families, homeowners, and business owners face unexpected moments, John approaches insurance with a simple belief: coverage should be clear before life gets complicated.
At Nauyokas Insurance Agency, John helps Indiana clients review their options, understand important policy details, and make informed decisions about protecting their homes, vehicles, families, businesses, and future. His goal is not just to help clients find a policy. It is to help them understand what they are choosing and why it matters.
Real-World Risk Experience
Clear Coverage Conversations
Protection Over Price
John’s emergency response and healthcare background gives him a practical understanding of why preparation matters before something goes wrong.
Nauyokas Insurance Agency explains insurance in straightforward language so clients can understand their coverage without feeling overwhelmed.
Price matters, but the cheapest policy is not always the right fit. John helps clients consider coverage limits, deductibles, exclusions, and long-term risk.
Why Nauyokas Insurance Agency Exists
Insurance should be clear before life gets complicated. Nauyokas Insurance Agency exists to help Indiana families and business owners understand their coverage, review important policy details, and make informed decisions before a claim, accident, storm, lawsuit, or major life change happens.
Meet the Nauyokas Insurance Agency Team
John Nauyokas
Agency Owner & Insurance Advisor
John Nauyokas founded Nauyokas Insurance Agency with a simple mission: to help people protect what matters most with clarity, honesty, and personal care.
Before entering the insurance industry, John spent years serving others as a firefighter, paramedic, and respiratory therapist. Those experiences shaped how he approaches insurance today. He understands the importance of preparation, protection, and being there for people when they need help most.
John believes insurance should be about relationships, education, and solutions, not just finding the cheapest policy. He works closely with clients to understand their needs and help build personalized protection plans for their homes, vehicles, businesses, and families.
Outside of the agency, John enjoys spending time with his wife Teresa, family, church community, woodworking, and supporting local businesses throughout Central Indiana.
Licensed in: Property & Casualty, Life, and Health Insurance
john@nauyokasins.com
Senior Insurance Advisor
With 28 years of insurance experience, Josh Reeser brings deep knowledge and steady guidance to the Nauyokas Insurance Agency team.
Josh has spent nearly three decades helping individuals, families, and business owners understand their options and make informed decisions about their coverage. His experience across personal and life insurance allows him to provide practical advice tailored to each client’s needs.
Known for his approachable personality and commitment to service, Josh takes pride in building lasting relationships and helping clients feel confident about their insurance decisions.
Licensed in: Property & Casualty, Life, and Health Insurance
josh@nauyokasins.com
Josh Reeser
Riley Ritzenthaler
Insurance Advisor
Riley Ritzenthaler helps clients review coverage options, ask the right questions, and feel more confident about their insurance decisions.
As a licensed Property & Casualty Insurance professional, Riley works closely with individuals and families to provide personal, attentive service. Her positive attitude, strong work ethic, and attention to detail make her an important part of the agency team.
Riley believes great service starts with listening, understanding, and building genuine relationships.
Licensed in: Property & Casualty Insurance
riley@nauyokasins.com
Madison McSwain
Madison McSwain brings a unique mix of entrepreneurial experience and client-focused service to Nauyokas Insurance Agency.
As the owner of Mind Over Mess, a professional organizing company, Madison understands the value of helping people simplify complicated situations and create peace of mind. She brings that same approach to insurance by helping clients better understand their options and make confident decisions.
Madison works with clients seeking auto, home, life, and health insurance solutions while staying focused on personal attention, clear communication, and dependable service.
Licensed in: Property & Casualty, Life,
and Health Insurance
Insurance Advisor
Teresa Nauyokas
Client Relations Coordinator
Teresa Nauyokas helps ensure clients receive the personal attention and care that define the Nauyokas Insurance Agency experience.
In addition to her role with the agency, Teresa serves as a Registered Nurse Case Manager. Her background in advocacy, communication, and problem-solving helps her create meaningful connections with clients and support them with care.
Teresa helps coordinate client communication, welcome letters, birthday greetings, and many of the personal touches that make clients feel valued long after they join the agency.
Licensed in: Property & Casualty Insurance
Grant Williams
Digital Marketing & Technology Coordinator
Grant Williams supports the agency’s website, digital marketing, and technology projects.
Working behind the scenes, Grant helps make it easier for clients to find, understand, and connect with Nauyokas Insurance Agency online. His work supports the agency’s digital presence, website experience, and ongoing growth strategy.
Grant helps the agency combine personal relationships with modern technology so clients can connect with the team more easily and confidently.
Business Insurance Guidance Built Around Your Risk
Every business has different risks, responsibilities, and coverage needs. Nauyokas Insurance Agency helps Indiana business owners review their operations, understand important policy details, and make informed decisions as their business changes.